Carmelo vs. LeBron: Rivalry Revived?

Remember 2003? When a freshman was taking the world by storm as a double-double machine in Syracuse while the entire world was focused on an 18-year-old already built like Thor, taking Ohio hostage? Those were good times, back when the hype had a chance to build on multiple levels, to see who was really the greatest. In other words, the coming of LeBron James and Carmelo Anthony was the biggest story in sports.

It had all the elements of the greatly aligned Magic and Bird rivalry: two young stars that have dominated everything amateur so completely that it looked like pros playing YMCA rec-league ball. When the ping pong balls came to play, there wasn’t a doubt about who would go first. That was already reserved for the precociousness that was LeBron. But it also really didn’t matter either, because Carmelo was going to land somewhere not too far after him and take that squad to the next level all the same.

Things played out like they were supposed to, kind of. LeBron went No. 1, and then Carmelo went No. 3 (let’s not even delve into the whys, what ifs and WTFs of him NOT going No. 2). It was set — let the young-gun rivalry take off. But something off-base happened. Carmelo didn’t bust really, but he also didn’t transcend. He quickly became one of the best scorers, then players, in the league, but it never really has amounted to much, especially when stacked up against LeBron. Like him or hate him, LeBron has done what he was supposed to do. Argue the extent if you’d like, but he’s held up his side of the bargain.

Carmelo stays relevant, but not in the fashion of ever-challenging for the best player in the game, which this rivalry was originally built on. At the risk of ragging on him, how he’s avoided the oh-so-common “overrated” tag is one of the most amazing things in all of sports. He’s a scorer without a scoring title, has topped out on the All-NBA second team (once) and is widely considered a “Top 10 player” without a Finals appearance with nearly 10 years in the game. Averaging nearly 25 points a night for a career is dope, but it sure hasn’t taken him to much more than a lot of popularity passes.

But now, Melo’s got a chance to change that. Both he and Bron are back  eye level with each other in the East, with the most UFC-worthy NBA rivalry in the last 20 years, the Miami Heat-New York Knicks, at their command. Is there still a chance to save this once hallowed personal rivalry-to-be? It’s early, but the Knicks are legit — it’s not too early to call that. They were legit last year, but it just wasn’t time yet. Too many pieces coming and going, and no chemistry at all. That’s working its way out now, and they may very well be the most complete club in the East. But all of that aside, the Heat are at the top of the mountain, and you can’t get knocked off of that before May.

The bottom line is it’s not Magic vs. Bird, and it never will be. But it’s not Kobe vs. LeBron either (because that’s never been). Just 10 years after the point, nobody even stacks Carmelo up versus LeBron anymore. The thrill is gone, but perhaps just temporarily. They won't face each other in an NBA Finals now, but that doesn’t mean that the revival of the Knicks can’t have them be in a Larry Bird vs. Dominque Wilkins style showdown, or even a Michael Jordan vs. Wilkins type of match-up. There’s still something to come of these two head up, and while Melo may never be MVP, scoring champ or anything else, he sure is in a fine position to be thwart to reign of the Heat.

Sometimes, great expectations get derailed by even harsher realities. The great expectation in this case was for the duo to trade off on championship seasons, to meet in the Finals and have epic, throwback, ESPN 2-worthy, NBA Films battles for the ring. But as things usually do, they changed. So in the rivalry revised, it serves as a proving point for LeBron, while a chance to justify what was supposed to be for Carmelo. At either rate, while it will never been what it was supposed to be, it’s not too late for it to be something. Something we haven’t seen in a long time.

10 Replies to “Carmelo vs. LeBron: Rivalry Revived?”

  1. I would never say that Carmelo is overrated. He was out in Denver balling but the West is a different kind of beast especially when you are playing with a bunch of guys who are good but can't stay healthy. When the Nuggets were healthy they made noise.

    It's good to see Melo get the credit he deserves as a player now. I thought that when he came to New York he would flourish. Instead in my opinion the team deferred to him too much and gave him the ball in spots on the floor that weren't suited for him to capitalize.

    Now he has a coach that he respects and understands his game. He has teammates who are perfect role players to compliment his skill set and barring injury a Carmelo Lebron rivalry would be good for the game.

    Good post. I like you see it more as a Bird vs. Dominique type of rivalry. Full of scoring and when you check the head to head numbers throughout the career Melo has been better. Not by a lot tho.

  2. All I want is a Miami/NY ECF.

    Game 7 in the Garden.

    In response to the article, 2003 was such an insane time. You knew the league was about to get a new batch of superstars (Wade's tournament run thrust him into the casual fan's consciousness, and even Bosh at Georgia Tech).

    My biggest regret from the class of '03 was T.J. Ford.

    Anywho, Bron/Melo isn't Magic/Bird for obvious reasons and while this is their 9th or 10th season, they're still 27/28. Like Matt said, there's still time for something to form.

  3. I never get the feeling that Carmelo has that burning desire. When I watch Kobe, Lebron, KG, even Duncan, I sense that not winning a championship would be a complete and utter catastrophe - a total waste of a season. Melo acts as if winning a championship would be great but he's not losing any sleep over it. Maybe that's a more healthy attitude, but fans want to see some blood, sweat and tears.

    1. I actually disagree with you there, JAG. I mean, Melo propelled Cuse to a national title, and in the NBA, he's the man who always wants the ball in the 4th quarter, wants to take that last shot, wants to be the one who takes over.

      Now, he's not as good as LeBron, Kobe, Duncan, KG in their primes, but I never watch Melo and think: That guy doesn't care about winning. Maybe he doesn't overtly show it the way KG & Kobe do, but the guy always seems to embrace the clutch moments and want to be there, in my opinion.

  4. @JAG If you bothered to watch any Knick game this season, you'd see that he's playing a lot of defense. Even when he's not scoring, he's affecting the game.

  5. Melo's playing defense?

    I'll concede that I haven't watched him much this year. Like most casual fans, I start watching the NBA at Christmas.

    If you say Carmelo has suddenly developed into a defensive stalwart, I'll take your word for it until I see otherwise.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.