Forget Tebowmania: Matt Barkley Makes A Statement

There has perhaps never been a more discussed nor more interesting third-string quarterback competition in NFL history than the one taking place for the Philadelphia Eagles this preseason.

That’s what happens when a once-heralded recruit out of high school, considered the best at his position in his class, is trying to resurrect his professional football career after seeing his star that was so bright at one of the nation’s top college football programs begin to fade. Oh, that also happens when the other guy in this competition is Tim Tebow.

What, you thought I was talking about the Heisman- and National Championship-winning Florida Gator? You can be forgiven, as Tebowmania is an unstoppable force thanks to all those fawning media types.

Of course, Tebow is the main attraction to outsiders in Chip Kelly’s search for a third signal-caller to back up new starter Sam Bradford and second-stringer Mark Sanchez. But in actuality, it’s that other former heralded high-schooler and collegiate who has the leg up in the competition. Following Philadelphia’s 36-10 drubbing of the Indianapolis Colts in the preseason opener Sunday, Matt Barkley still holds a pretty sizable edge.

Yesterday, Barkley and Tebow played the majority of the contest, with Bradford inactive and Sanchez ending his day after just two possessions, and it was clear that Barkley outperformed Tebow.

This makes sense, seeing as Barkley has had a full year under Kelly to learn the offense, and it showed. For the first time in his professional career, Barkley looked confident and had complete command in the huddle. He made quick decisions, got the ball out swiftly and moved the Eagles’ offense efficiently against a disinterested Indy defense. Yes, he did throw an interception on a batted ball, but overall, Barkley looked like a competent QB who knew exactly what to do with each throw.

This is new, seeing as Barkley has looked like a deer in headlights in the brief NFL game action he’s seen during his previous two seasons in the league.

On Sunday, it was Tebow who looked out of his element. After a very impressive first drive in which Tebow made quick reads and pinpoint throws, he continually held on to the ball too long, failed to decipher the defense, and showcased his penchant to make mistakes instead of just throwing the ball away and living to fight another play. He wasn’t altogether terrible, at times looking good with both his arm and feet, including a rushing touchdown to his credit, but for anyone with eyes, it was clear Tebow is more than a few steps behind Barkley in just about every phase of the offense.

This shouldn’t come as a surprise, despite the struggles of Barkley during his first two NFL seasons. After all, Barkley entered college football with the same type of pedigree as Tebow, and as recently as his junior year, Barkley was touted as potentially the No. 1 pick in the NFL Draft.

Coming out of football factory Mater Dei High School in California, Barkley was the Gatorade National Player of the Year, and ironically following Mark Sanchez’s reign as starter for USC, Barkley became the first true freshman to ever start at quarterback in the opener for the Trojans.

His first three years were stellar, and there was no reason to think Barkley’s decision to return for his senior year would do any harm to his NFL chances. Of course, that didn’t account for Barkley spraining his shoulder and losing arm strength as a result.

USC struggled, Barkley’s stock plummeted and after getting some intrigue at the draft when the Eagles selected him in the fourth round, the world seemed to forget about Matt Barkley. He admittedly did nothing to earn any notoriety in his first two seasons in the league, barely seeing the field. The few times he did, he was awful, tossing three interception and losing a fumble without recording a single touchdown — passing or rushing, to his name.

Barkley’s struggles, coupled with Kelly’s penchant for taking chances, are what led the Eagles to bring Tebow in this season in the first place, and I admit that before the preseason actually started, I thought Tebow had more than a strong chance to overtake what had previously been an impotent Matt Barkley thus far in midnight green.

Yet yesterday, Barkley showcased the type of tools that had him at the top of a whole hell of a lot of draft boards after his junior season to begin with. At 6’2”, he has decent size, and his quick decision-making and strong accuracy — he’s been 60 percent completion percentage every season but his freshman year at USC, when he had a 59.9 percent completion percentage — that NFL coaches love and NFL offenses demand. And he did it in a commanding way, looking like the confidant quarterback he was in college as he enters his third professional season.

Matt Barkley started four years at USC for a reason. He was the Gatorade High School Player of the Year for a reason. He was considered a top pick before his final season for a reason. And there was a reason the Eagles took him in the fourth round and have kept him around ever since.

Yesterday, he showed why. Ultimately, it may not mean anything. It’s not as if Barkley, off the strength of one preseason game, is going to thrust himself into a starting-caliber QB or even a second-stringer. The allure of Tim Tebow, who has had NFL success despite his obvious flaws, may prove to be too much for Chip Kelly to ignore.

But it is clear that at this point, Matt Barkley is the better fit for the Philadelphia Eagles for a position they hope they won’t need to utilize at all this season. So go ahead and keeping showing the Tim Tebow highlights while completely ignoring Matt Barkley, ESPN. He doesn’t care. He’s just going to keep going out there and showcasing that Tim Tebow isn’t the only heralded collegiate QB fighting for his NFL life.

4 Replies to “Forget Tebowmania: Matt Barkley Makes A Statement”

  1. Barkley TDs = 0, INTs = 1
    Tebow TDs = 1, INTs = 0

    Tebow up +2 in the TD-Turnover differential ober Barkley. Tebow leads the competition in the eyes of a smart coach
    The number one stat in football is turnovers. Thats why Tebow has been historically successful and has a winning record in the NFL.
    Barkely is a turnover machine as repeated Sunday. Nearly threw 2 more too! 0 career TDs to 4 career INTs for Barkley. 43 qb career qb rating. Doesnt get much lower.

    1. “The number one stat in football is turnovers.” I totally agree. And I totally agree with the reasoning as to why Barkley has been terrible in the 4 games he’s played in his career and Tebow had some success.

      But clearly you either didn’t read the article or didn’t watch the game, because it was evident that Barkley ran the offense more efficiently Sunday than Tebow did. Sure, Tebow had a rushing touchdown. Barkley also led the Eagles on a TD drive. But watching them back there in the huddle and pocket, Barkley was making decisions quicker and better, whereas Tebow took a long time to make his reads, which is why he hasn’t been in the NFL in a couple years.

      1. Doesn’t make any difference if you are going quicker only to mess up. Barkley had 1 INT but nearly though 3 if I recall. He has a history in prior years, 2015 training camp and now this game of turning the ball over. This is not the formula for a winning team. Eagles should let him go now.

        1. There obviously are 3 more games for this to shake out, and I wouldn’t be surprised at all if that’s exactly what happens. You have to think Tebow will get better command of the offense, etc., but that was the whole point of this post – Barkley looked a whole lot more confidant than he has at all so far in his career.

          Was he perfect? No, not at all. But he also moved the Birds up and down the field and made the proper reads quickly more times than not – something Tebow didn’t do Sunday. Sure, Tebow had some success and looked really good on the first drive and the TD drive, whereas Barkley made some bad throws, but overall, the offense was more fluid and moved better with Barkley under center Sunday.

          I don’t disagree with any of your criticisms of Barkley whatsoever. What I’m saying is he looked better than he has previously and overall better than Tebow – in my opinion – on Sunday. I certainly wouldn’t cut him based of Sunday’s performance. I mean, we are talking about third-string here.

          Though I do believe Tebow provides more intriguing options with his running ability and trick play scenarios. Thanks for reading. I truly mean that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *