As known from:
VA
US Gambling Sites / Underdog Fantasy Review / Underdog Fantasy Pick'em 2025

Underdog Fantasy Pick'em 2025: Check Underdog Pick'em Legal States & Rules

Last Updated on 16/03/2025
Fact checked by: Drew the DFS Guy

Underdog Fantasy Pick’ em provides you with the chance to filter through individual stats and/or compare two rivals to find the perfect selections for your contest entries.

You can choose to find athletes from a number of top sports, combine both rivals and higher/lower selections, and decide whether you wish to insure your contest entries. Plus, as things stand, you can pick up a 100% matched bonus and a free Pick’ em entry by using the exclusive bonus code CAPTAINFAN.

Underdog Fantasy
DFS Promo
4.6/5
Claim your Special Pick via Code + First Time Deposit up to $250 in bonus!
Deposit Bonus
|
T&Cs and 18+ apply
Copy
Play now
Underdog Fantasy Highlights
  • Well designed DFS website and mobile app
  • Generous welcome bonus for new customers
  • Great fantasy tournaments for the NFL and NBA
Underdog Fantasy player pick
Underdog Fantasy: Pros & Cons
  • Legal in most US states
  • Option to insure your contest entries
  • Claim a free entry using exclusive code: CAPTAINFAN
  • All major sports covered
  • Maximum value of contest entry is capped

The basics: What is Underdog Fantasy Pick ’em?

The Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em is a daily fantasy sports contest that can be enjoyed by all verified members of the platform. As with most DFS betting sites, Underdog offers users the chance to build their own rosters across a range of popular sports. However, they also present a unique take on the DFS experience by providing you with the chance to create a multiple-selection entry based on 1 v 1 matchups (Rivals) and individual performances (higher/lower).

How does Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em work?

As briefly touched upon, the Underdog Fantasy Pick’em is based around two key categories: Rivals and higher/lower.

Rivals

You can create part or all of your Pick ‘em entries by checking out eligible Rivals. This portion of the Pick ‘em DFS contest requires you to select which athlete you believe will outperform the other in a certain stat group.

For instance, you may find that an Underdog Fantasy football matchup is offering you a Rivals one-on-one between Adam Thielen and Cole Kmet. You will be tasked with deciding who you believe will receive the most receiving yards in their upcoming match. Of course, to level the playing field, you’ll find that a points adjustment has been added to Cole Kmet, meaning that this will need to be taken into account.

To add your selection to your Pick ‘em entry, you’ll need to simply click on the athlete you believe will win the 1 v 1 battle, including any points additions. Once between 2 and 5 selections have been added to your entry, you can look to back your predictions up to the value of $250.

Higher/Lower

As the name suggests, the higher/lower Pick ‘em category provides you with the chance to decide whether your chosen athlete will surpass predictions or fail to reach a preset target.

When heading to the higher/lower section of the site or mobile app, you’ll find that you can filter by sport and upcoming fixture. Once you’ve chosen a fixture you plan to follow, you’ll find a number of players with a range of possible outcomes attached. For instance, you may be able to predict whether Victor Hedman will have more or less than 0.5 assists in an upcoming NHL fixture.

To add your selection to your Pick ‘em entry, you need to choose ‘higher’ or ‘lower’ on the relevant stat. This will then be added to your entry. It is also worth noting that you can use your Underdog Fantasy deposit match on Pick ‘em entries, too.

Underdog Fantasy
DFS Deposit Bonus
Claim your Special Pick via Code + First Time Deposit up to $250 in bonus!
T&Cs and 18+ apply
Code
Copy
Claim Promo

Creating your entries: Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em rules

With the basics now under your belt, it is time to provide you with a brief overview of some key rules to help you understand the entry process further.

  1. To begin, entries must contain athletes from at least two different teams or sports
  2. All entries must consist of between two and five selections, excluding those entering contests in Colorado
  3. As part of the new customer offer, you will find that you can unlock a 100% deposit match of up to $100 and claim a free Fantasy Pick ‘em entry. You just need to remember to use the exclusive bonus code: CAPTAINFAN
  4. Underdog Fantasy will void any selection with athletes that get injured before the match takes place or during the early portion of the fixture
  5. If one pick pushes, the selection will be removed from your entry. Your entry will then be reduced by one selection, and any payouts will reflect this
  6. If a valid selection ends in a tie, your entry will be deemed a win. However, it will pay out for the number of active entries
  7. If a tie turns an entry invalid, your initial contest entry will be voided and refunded

Underdog Pick ’em insurance: Add some security to your entries

Alongside the basic rules surrounding Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em contests, you’ll find that a couple of variations are provided – insured entries and uninsured entries.

In short, insured entries provide you with a small security blanket of one failed selection. However, as you would expect, the payouts aren’t quite as high as uninsured entries. Of course, should your uninsured entries lose by one selection, your whole entry will be deemed a loss.

Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em payout

In this convenient table, you’ll find out all you need to know about the potential payouts of insured and uninsured entries to help establish the right approach for you. Bear in mind that you may also stumble across a boost, enhancing payouts to a possible 60x.

Number of selections With or Without Insurance? Correct number of picks Payout
Two Without Two 3x your entry
Three Without Three 6x your entry
Three With Two 1x your entry
Three With Three 3x your entry
Four Without Four 10x your entry
Four With Three 1.5x your entry
Four With Four 6x your entry
Five Without Five 20x your entry
Five With Four 2.5x your entry
Five With Five 10x your entry

You’ll be pleased to hear that Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em is legal in almost all US states. Currently, only those located in Connecticut, Hawaii, Idaho, Nevada, Louisiana, Montana, Washington, Delaware, and Iowa are excluded from Underdog entirely. With those residing in California, Ohio, Maryland, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Texas, Alabama, Florida, and Georgia unable to create Pick ‘em entries.

As extensively covered in our Underdog Fantasy review, you’ll find that there are a few state-specific restrictions to consider before creating your Underdog Pick ‘em entries, too. For example, those based in Colorado must create entries with a minimum of four selections. Fortunately, all of this is available to review before ever creating your account.

Register, redeem, and create your Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em entries today

There you have it, a quick summary of what you can expect from the Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em contests. Although not available in all US states, most avid sports fans will be able to grab a piece of the action online or through the Underdog Fantasy app.

Once you’ve worked your way through the registration process and unlocked the exclusive 100% deposit match bonus, you’ll be free to begin building your Underdog Pick ‘em entries using a combination of Rivals and higher/lower selections. Payouts will vary depending on whether you insure your entries, maxing out at 20x – unless, of course, you manage to secure one of those impressive 60x boosts.

DFS Promo
4.6/5
Underdog Fantasy
DFS Promo
4.6/5
Claim your Special Pick via Code + First Time Deposit up to $250 in bonus!
Deposit Bonus
|
T&Cs and 18+ apply
Copy
Claim Promo

Underdog Fantasy Pick ’em FAQ

📱 How do I build an Underdog Fantasy Pick ’em entry?

After filtering through the ‘Rivals’ and ‘Higher/Lower’ options, you need to click on your preferred athlete or the higher/lower button to add a selection to your entry. A minimum of two selections must be added before you can confirm your contest submission.

🏈 Can I use various sports to create an Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em entry?

Yes. In fact, it is actively encouraged at Underdog Fantasy to use a range of fixtures and sports to build your entries. As a rule, you’ll need to use a minimum of two different fixtures. However, different sports are also considered eligible.

Will I be able to use my bonus on an Underdog Fantasy Pick ‘em entry?

Absolutely. Underdog Fantasy has a fantastic welcome bonus offering you the chance to redeem a 100% deposit match of up to $100 and a free Pick ‘em contest entry. Just remember to enter the exclusive promotional code: CAPTAINFAN.

Top Brands
Top Promos
Underdog Fantasy
Underdog Fantasy
Underdog Fantasy Review
4.6/5
ParlayPlay
ParlayPlay
ParlayPlay Review
4.6/5
OwnersBox
OwnersBox
OwnersBox Review
4.5/5
DraftKings Fantasy
DraftKings Fantasy
DraftKings Fantasy Review
4.5/5
Boom Fantasy
Boom Fantasy Review
4.5/5
Underdog Fantasy
Underdog Fantasy Promo
Claim your Special Pick via Code + First Time Deposit up to $250 in bonus!
T&Cs apply
4.6/5
ParlayPlay
ParlayPlay Promo
100% up to $100
T&Cs apply
4.6/5
OwnersBox
OwnersBox Promo
100% up to $500
T&Cs apply
4.5/5
DraftKings Fantasy
DraftKings Fantasy Promo
20% up to $500
18+ in most eligible states, but age varies by jurisdiction. Eligibility restrictions apply.
4.5/5
Boom Fantasy Promo
up to $100 No Sweat First Entry
T&Cs apply
4.5/5
Latest Sport News
Could Caitlin Clark Play in the NBA?
There’s no question that Caitlin Clark is revolutionizing ...
The Best NBA Teams to Not Win an NBA Finals
Who remembers the team that loses the NBA ...
Which WNBA Star Will Challenge Caitlin Clark the Next Decade?
When it comes to the future of “The ...
MLB Daily Picks:
Drew's DFS Picks
Our Team
Mark LewisJosh SchwartzDan HolmesDrew the DFS GuyMike Goodpaster
Mark Lewis
Mark Lewis
Editor
Josh Schwartz
Josh Schwartz
Editor
Dan Holmes
Dan Holmes
Sports Writer
Drew the DFS Guy
Drew the DFS Guy
DFS Expert
Mike Goodpaster
Mike Goodpaster
Editor
Get the latest updates in Sports and Casino via our Newsletter

21+ and present in VA. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

This site is using Cloudflare and adheres to the Google Safe Browsing Program. We adapted Google's Privacy Guidelines to keep your data safe at all times.
Virginia Town HallCloudflareSSLco² neutral
Close
Our Sports Pros recommend these awesome Daily Fantasy sites this week:
ParlayPlay
ParlayPlay Promo
100% up to $100
T&Cs and 18+ apply
Code:
Open ParlayPlay
Claim Promo
Underdog Fantasy
Underdog Fantasy Promo
Claim your Special Pick via Code + First Time Deposit up to $250 in bonus!
T&Cs and 18+ apply
Code:
Open Underdog Fantasy
Claim Promo
×
Your Promo Code:
The bonus offer of Underdog Fantasy was already opened in an additional window. If not, you can open it also by clicking the following link:
Play now